It’s ‘just the job’

Look around your English department. There are probably around ten people in it, right? Maybe slightly more or less, but let’s take that as an average. Day in, day out, they plan lessons and they input data and they prepare for exam classes, and you’d think that they’re basically okay.

Except for that one guy. He’s the one who looks visibly exhausted. Who talks about it in the staffroom, ashen-faced. Who gets to Friday and looks drained, and who always seems to be there until 7pm each night (and who you suspect probably works when he gets home too). He’s not going to last. He’s not got what it takes. He’ll be out in the next year, either by capability procedures or by his own means. That’s the reality of the job, isn’t it?

Only it’s not. Look again at that department – at your colleagues who express a frazzled weariness at the new English Language GCSE, who are worn out by the endless cycle of marking, who are already now dreading your March moderation meeting and who talk about spending their whole weekend on their books. Of them, eight of them are stressed. Five of them are so stressed that they are considering leaving teaching entirely. Sure, they don’t show it as visibly as that one guy, but they’re feeling it. Maybe they don’t have what it takes either. They need to develop better strategies. They’ll be out within three to five years, and good riddance. The system needs new blood.

Now look at the two people – maybe three, if we’re feeling optimistic – who seem to be coping. Both in the profession less than five years, but thriving, even. With a TLR behind them and a seemingly limitless ability to handle the pressure that’s thrown at them. Their books are marked, their lessons are planned, and they are SLT material given time, no question. The school needs more people like them. Britain’s students do. Why can’t everyone be like them?

Occasionally one of the department goes to its Head and tells them that they’re stressed. Depending on what day of the week it is, he may listen patiently and tell them, “this is the job”. Alternatively, he may laugh bitterly, and tell them, “we all are. This is the job.” This is what you signed up for, so get used to it. Eventually, that one guy will go to him and say, “I can’t handle this”, and he will be told, “maybe this isn’t the job for you.” And he will leave, and he will be replaced.

In any other industry in the country, if 83% of your workforce were routinely stressed and 52% so stressed that they’re considering leaving, it would be clear that the problem wasn’t the people but the job. Managers would be tasked with fixing it, hours would be changed, policies adjusted and their impact measured. Something would be done.

In any other industry in the country, when you were taking your most motivated, driven and passionate people and they were being burned out within three years, you would say that there was a problem with what they were being asked to do – that something you were doing as an organisation was not working. You would realise that you were haemorrhaging talent, and that kind of haemorrhage wasn’t sustainable. You wouldn’t hold up the 20% that were succeeding as a triumph, you’d lament the fact that 80% weren’t just ‘failing to cope’ but were actively being destroyed by the job.

Instead the members of that English staffroom are being told that it’s just the job, and if they aren’t cut out for it, then maybe they should move on.

It can’t be the job for much longer. It mustn’t be.

It’s ‘just the job’

6 thoughts on “It’s ‘just the job’

  1. Sounds like a story I’ve read many times before. It is unfortunate no one is prepared to do anything about it; maybe strike action is the best solution although this doesn’t seem to have worked for the junior doctors.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m encouraged by Doug Lemov and the Michaela folks, though – their relentless focus on finding out what works and pursuing it suggests there’s hope for the job yet. A lot of what they do seems (whisper it) sustainable.

      I just reckon it will be five years before people really sit up and take notice on a national scale, and that might be too late

      Liked by 2 people

  2. Put absolutely beautifully and completely true of my experience of working in other sectors. Is it perfect? No. Is there bad practice/bosses that are horrible/managers that don’t understand? Yes. Is this as widespread as in teaching? No, quite frankly it isn’t. My relationship with my line manager right now is completely brilliant. I do the work to the best of my abilities, work hard, take my responsibilities seriously and go to them with problems (and solutions if I have them). I don’t feel I have to be perfect – just a bloody good worker. This is what I would have wanted as a teacher but never got – the fact is that when it comes to management in particular, other industries are better because managers are picked on their ability to be good at the job. In teaching, this is not the case and that causes huge problems. Good teachers don’t necessarily make good managers and the training given is utterly appalling. It’s one of the reasons I left because if all there is is the opportunity to become a bullying Deputy Head, then no thanks, there are other ways of making a living.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks Tarjinder, that’s kind of you. When I’ve considered leaving, those have been the two big motivations: not wanting to climb that ladder (who needs the stress of being a HoD?) and wanting an understanding Line Management. My HoD now is amazing, but doing what he can within a skewed system; there are limits to what he can do.

      I do think that lack of autonomy is causing a lot of problems now, and I see why people are drawn to the private sector at times.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s